If I say that I just did a quick tally of the historical romance keepers on one of my eight overflowing bookshelves and counted 180, you will have some idea of how daunting I found the task of selecting five favorite couples from among all the characters I have loved in historical romance. After a long struggle, I persuaded myself that it would be acceptable to fudge the assignment a bit and choose five top couples from 20th century romance novels and five from 21st century romance novels. I’m allying myself with the purists for the purpose of this list and not counting Jane Austen as a historical romance author, although I certainly include Elizabeth Bennet and Fitzwilliam Darcy and Anne Elliot and Frederick Wentworth among my favorite fictional couples.
Top 5 Couples from 20th-century Romance Novels
(in order of publication since I cannot choose among them)
1. Frederica Merrivale and the Marquis of Alverstoke, Frederica (1965) by Georgette Heyer
Frederica is my favorite Heyer for many reasons. Certainly one of those reasons is the pairing of Frederica, one of Heyer’s intelligent, competent heroines, and the arrogant, self-centered Alverstoke who grow in love rather than falling in love. I delight in Alverstoke’s bewilderment over what is happening to him: “Then came Frederica, upsetting his cool calculations, thrusting responsibilities upon him, intruding more and more into the ordered pattern of his life, and casting him into a state of unwelcome doubt.” They truly are the best thing that ever happened to one another.