Sep 6 2012 9:30am

An Auspicious Career: A Tribute to Carla Kelly’s Regencies

Beau Crusoe by Carla Kelly

Dear Editor:

Sorry I’m late handing in this Carly Kelly tribute, but every time I opened a Carla Kelly novel to see if I could find an example, I ended up settling down for a good read.

In case you’re not a fan yet, allow me to introduce Ms. Kelly. She is the author of over forty books and short stories. Most famous for what she dubs “dukeless” Regencies, her plots usually revolve around ordinary people in stories set during the United Kingdom of the early 1800s. She also writes Westerns, but the books I’ve read, and try to force other people to read, are her Regencies. During the '90s she won all sorts of prizes, including a couple of RITAs.

At long last, her early books are available for e-readers. My favorites are the ones featuring naval heroes because she’s so good at setting the scene. I also have a soft spot for Beau Crusoe, about a hero who’s been stranded on a desert island for a few years. She does damaged men so well in all her books.

Marrying the Captain by Carla KellyHold on, I just got to check this scene in Marrying the Captain for what?  Non-anachronistic language. Yup, she’s good at her world-building, yeah, that’s a given. She’s a real historian by training.  And there aren’t info dumps, the historical bits are so firmly woven into the plot you won’t notice them. (No one does the tone of life on a sailing ship better. I’m looking at you, Patrick O’Brien.) No, wait, I forgot that I’m looking for…


When I think Carla Kelly’s Regency romances, the word “sexual” isn’t the first thing to pop into my head. Passion and sexuality is there, of course, discreetly covered, just the way a lady’s ankle should be hidden. You can find good doses of tension, of course. In Austen, ladies have trouble raising their eyes to meet the ardent gaze of gentlemen.

Kelly is more graphic than Austen, but still, her characters’ attitudes feel appropriate for their time.  Don’t get me wrong—I like flat out undisguised sexual fun as much as anyone, but I’m not always convinced that Regency characters, at least the gently bred ones, would allow sexual appetite to form the basis of their intercourse with the opposite gender.

As Hartley said, “The past is a foreign country: they do things differently there." We’re all animals, of course, with the same set of urges, but they were trained up differently than us and I think a lot of writers have trouble conveying that long-lost norm for genteel society.

In a Kelly book, a gentleman notices a lady’s fine, neat figure but, unless they’re intimate, or about to be, he’s not going to wonder how her breasts will feel in his hands, or if he does, it’ll be a passing thought that perhaps embarrasses him. They don’t objectify one another.

Marrying the Royal Marine by Carla KellyA good example is in Marrying the Royal Marine, the hero undresses and baths the heroine when she is vilely seasick. He notes her discomfort and her bravery. He doesn’t dwell on her body, although of course he does notice her. 

With their honor, valor, honorable intentions, yadayada her heroes and heroines should be a bunch of dull Mary (or Marty) Sues, but she makes sure they’re human. It’s just that with all that decency and discretion Kelly characters sometimes seem like a sub-species, creatures far rarer than the standard Romanticus Heroii. They certainly don’t come across as anything modern, so that’s all part and parcel of her writing about a time that’s not our own.

Yet maybe her world is just as much of a fiction as any historical in which young virgins openly cavort with gentlemen and don’t lose their reputation. In Kelly’s case, the fairy-tale is that her main characters are unfailingly decent and upright (and get your mind out of the gutter, that’s not the upright they mean), even when they’re ardent or passionate or in lust.

I love spending time with them, even if they do seem more alien than many of the vampires and shape-shifters I’ve read lately.


Kate Rothwell writes romance using her own name and the pseudonym Summer Devon. She lives in Connecticut with four men (three of whom are her sons). You can out more about her at and

Subscribe to this conversation (must be logged in):
1. Gayle63
You've inspired me to seek out some of Carla's books. I love a good historical! :) I wonder if the Downtown Abbey craze (which I'm definitely part of!) will increase demand for these. I hope so.
Heather Waters
2. HeatherWaters
You know, I don't think I've ever read Carla Kelly. *hangs head in shame* It's really cool that she writes about ordinary characters, though, so I'll have to rectify this soon.
Darlene Marshall
3. DarleneMarshall
Carla Kelly's been on my autobuy list for years, and I often pull out Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand or The Wedding Journey for a good sobfest. I have read her western collection, Here's to the Ladies, and I think she brings the American West to life even more effectively than she brings Regency England to life.
4. KateRothwell
I've been afraid of her westerns, but I think I'll have to get over that now. I wonder if Wendy Crutcher knows about them
5. kui
I love Carla Kelly! I discovered her stories last year through my kindle recommends feature, but after reading 'The Admirals Penniless Bride' & 'Marrying the Royal Marine' I thought where have you been all my life. It was refreshing to read a historical that didnt didnt involve the upper crust (which I didnt know I was lacking until Ms. Kelly) and where the heroes were just nice, honorable gentlemen. side-note: I believe she recently started writing faith-based (mormon) romance(nothing wrong with that), but thats not my cup of tea- so if its not yours either I would be sure to read the book description before purchase.
6. Rose In RoseBear
Carla Kelly's With This Ring is one of the very best Regencies I have ever read. It pushes all my emotional buttons, and when I read the letter at the end, I sigh and smile.

The military men ring true, and the heroine is really a heroine, standing up for what is right when she knew it would wreck her life.

I have several of her books, but the titles that are now in e-format are new to me. Yay! New stuff!
Mary Lynne Nielsen
7. emmel
Carla Kelly is a goddess. If you haven't read her, and you enjoy historicals, give her a try. @rose: Yup, With This Ring is my fave, too.
8. Janga
I think I've read all of Carla Kelly's Regency novels and novellas, and there's not a bad one in the bunch. Reforming Lord Ragsdale is my favorite. Even rereading it and knowing that Emma and John get their HEA, my heart is in my throat as I wonder how Kelly will ever overcome the obstacles. When I first read Mrs. Drew Plays Her Hand, I loved it because Roxanna Drew, unlike most widows I encountered in historicals, had enjoyed a happy first marriage, grieved her husband sincerely, and missed a healthy sex life.
I also love Libby's London Merchant and the twist on who the hero is and One Good Turn, which has the best redeemed villain ever IMO. And then there are all those wonderful Christmas stories. Nobody is better than Carla Kelly at revealing the extraordinary in the lives of ordinary people.

And I second the recommendation of Here's to the Ladies. “Kathleen Flaherty’s Long Winter,” reminiscent of The Wedding Journey, and "Jesse MacGregor" are particularly strong.
Susan Scherzlein
9. Susan Scherzlein
Janga, I couldn't agree with you more! I am so pleased to see Carla Kelly featured here. She is one of my absolute favorite Regency authors, and one I would have no trouble recommending to people who don't read romance novels at all. Her characters are human and it's no stretch to believe that they would act the way she writes them. It's always a good day when a new Carla Kelly novel comes out!
Post a comment