Wed
Apr 8 2015 3:30pm

The Sisterhood of Spinsterhood: 8 Firmly On-the-Shelf Romance Heroines from Austen, Hoyt, Kleypas, and More!

Persuasion by Jane AustenSpinster (noun): A woman beyond the typical age of marrying with little likelihood to do so.

A crueler name disguised in polite society could not have been created for our historical romance heroines. Yet, the spinster trope is a beloved favorite. Why? Because these are the women that have either chosen spinsterhood because they are strong and independent women who don’t need a man to complete them, or their beauty hasn’t had an opportunity to shine. And I always like to root for the underdog or read about the impossible HEA waiting to unravel. Finally, these spinster courtships have been some of the most memorable, whether it is due to the spinster’s wit or the bottled up passion waiting to be unleashed.

Below is a list of some of my favorite spinster historical romance stories in alphabetical order by author.

Jane Austen’s Persuasion

Is any list of spinsters complete without our beloved Anne Elliot? After being persuaded to break her engagement to naval officer, Frederick Wentworth, Anne gets another chance at love. Eight years later, and a life-time of regret, Anne comes face to face with her former fiancé, now a successful and respected Captain. What ensues is a masterpiece in second chances, courtship, and chemistry.

A Good Rogue is Hard to Find by Kelly BowenKelly Bowen’s A Good Rogue is Hard to Find

Miss Jenna Hughes has resigned herself to singledom. In fact, she would like nothing more than to remain the companion to the eccentric Dowager Duchess of Worth. Because Jenna is no ordinary companion. She and the duchess are intent on righting the ton’s wrongs by redistributing wealth from the rich to the poor. The poor being shopkeepers and merchants forced into bankruptcy when the ton refuses to deliver payment for services already rendered. Only Jenna does not anticipate the Dowager’s son, William Somerhall, Duke of Worth, to meddle in their affairs, nor to win her heart. Banter and chemistry are at an all-time high with this gem.

Elizabeth Hoyt’s Duke of Midnight

The sixth book in the Maiden Lane series, Hoyt takes us back to London of the 1700s. Artemis Greaves is a lady’s companion to her beautiful, yet witless cousin, Penelope. At 28, Artemis is well resigned to the ranks of spinsterhood, in part due to the injustice handed to her twin brother when he was imprisoned in Bedlam for a crime he didn’t commit. When her cousin sets her eyes on Maximus Batten, Duke of Wakefield, aka one of the Ghosts of St. Giles, Artemis finds herself consumed by his attentions and their forbidden affair. And Maximus finds he can no longer hide his true affections, as Artemis melts his hardened exterior.

Lisa Kleypas’s Married by Morning

Before I get a verbal flogging for not including Devil in Winter, let me just say that I love that book as well. And it is the quintessential spinster/rogue novel. However, I want to give a shout out to one of her other series, the Hathaways. And Married by Morning has to be my favorite. Catherine Marks, a paid companion to the younger Hathaway sisters, makes a place for herself in this quirky family fallen into aristocracy through an inheritance from a distant relative. More importantly, Catherine has safety and protection. All is well with the family, save the male heir to the Ramsay estate, Leo Hathaway. Hidden beneath their constant bickering is an attraction that will have readers swooning and falling in love with one of my most favorite historical romance couples.

Vivienne Lorret’s The Devilish Mr. Danvers

The second in the Rakes of Fallow Hall series, the Devilish Mr. Danvers is set for release April 21.  After Rafe Danvers was left at the altar by his fiancée, Ursa Sinclair, he vows never to marry again, lest he be made a fool twice. Hedley Sinclair, younger sister to Ursa, and the family’s dark secret, finally has a chance to realize her independence. No longer confined to the attic of her mother’s home after inheriting Greyson Park from her grandfather, she sets out to make the most of her home, regardless of the fact that is in ruins. The only problem is that Rafe Danvers also owns Greyson Park. What starts out as a battle for the property turns into a battle of the heart. And this is Lorret’s finest thus far.

A Rogue by Any Other Name by Sarah MacLeanSarah MacLean’s A Rogue by Any Other Name

Let me start out by saying that Nine Rules to Break While Romancing a Rake is my most treasured spinster novel. However, I wanted to give kudos to another most excellent spinster novel from her Rules of Scoundrel Series. After Lady Penelope Marbury faced a broken engagement from Simon Pearson, the Duke of Disdain (whom I’ve now renamed the Duke of Dreamy), Penelope finds herself quite on the shelf. That is, until she is forced into an unlikely courtship with none other than her childhood friend, Michael, Marquess of Bourne. Only the years have hardened Michael and it will take a woman as spirited and spectacular as Penelope to uncover the true Michael she once loved.

Mary Jo Putney’s The Rake

Formerly The Rake and the Reformer, this RITA winning novel tugs at the heartstrings. Reginald Davenport, once the heir apparent to an earldom, now a veritable rake and drunkard, is offered one final chance of redemption. When the new Earl of Margrave decides to give Davenport an unentailed property, Strickland, Reginald sets out to return to the place he once called home. Now thriving under the stewardship of an A. E. Weston, imagine his surprise when he learns that his steward is none other than Lady Alys Weston. Reggie and Alys begin an unlikely friendship that blossoms into much more as they begin to heal from their pasts.

Julia Quinn’s The Viscount Who Loved Me

Ack, this was a toss-up between Kate’s story and Penelope Featherington’s from Romancing Mister Bridgerton. Anthony Bridgerton, Viscount and head of the Bridgertons has finally decided to marry. And he chooses none other than Edwina Sheffied, the incomparable of the season. The only thing, or person, standing in his way is Edwina’s sister, Kate. And once they begin their sparring dance, the pall mall balls fly and love conquers all fears.

What are your favorite Spinster novels? 

 

Learn more about or order a copy of the books mentioned in this post:

Persuasion by Jane Austen  
A Good Rogue is Hard to Find by Kelly Bowen (out 4/28)  
Duke of Midnight by Elizabeth Hoyt  
Married by Morning by Lisa Kleypas  
The Devilish Mr. Danvers by Vivienne Lorret (out 4/21)  
A Rogue by Any Other Name by Sarah MacLean  
The Rake by Mary Jo Putney  
The Viscount Who Loved Me by Julia Quinn  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Tanya is a fanatic of all things romance and teaches sociology part time. You can follow her on twitter @tamushamu.

Subscribe to this conversation (must be logged in):
5 comments
lauralee1912
1. lauralee1912
My new favorite spinster/rake story is His Wicked Reputation by Madeline Hunter which I enjoyed because there was a mystery involved as well. Spinster stories are big favorites of mine and many of my favorites hit this list. It is hard to pick between The Devil in Winter and Married by Morning.
Heather Waters
2. HeatherWaters
Married by Morning and The Viscount Who Loved Me are both favorites, as is Persuasion, of course. Sounds like I need to read the Vivenne Lorret for sure--thanks for the recs!
Maria Acevedo
3. Maria Acevedo
Kate Sheffield wasn't really a spinster. She was only 21 or 22. They just thought Edwina had a better chance to shine and hoped her having a good match would help them all.

Penelope and Eloise were spinsters.

Apart from that... great list.
TanyaLK
4. TanyaLK
Hi Maria-
Yep, fair enough, she was just about to turn 21- But back then that was still quite old for her first season and because she was so old, they didn't really think she would have a chance of marrying, especially next to Edwina. And it mentions that if they waited one more year for Edwina to be 18, "But that would have made Kate nearly twent-two, and heavens, but who would have married her then?" Which is why I included her - so maybe she can be our non-traditional spinster, lol.

Penelope and Eloise were definitely a bit older. And I do love Romancing Mr. Bridgerton. I had a hard time deciding...
TanyaLK
5. TanyaLK
@Lauralee1912 I'll have to read the Madeline Hunter-
@HeatherWaters I really do love Lorret's new one. Hedley is such an awesome heroine/spinster.
Post a comment