Thu
Feb 2 2012 11:30am

Dirty Cowboys: The Allure of the Gritty Western Romance

Hell on Wheels imageI hadn’t expected a show called Hell on Wheels to be full of romance, but it does bring some familiar character types readers of gritty western historical romance will easily recognize: There’s an embittered Confederate veteran, out for revenge on the Yankees who killed his wife and child, the refined British widow who adapts to the raw and untamed frontier while proving her true mettle, a former slave who may be doing more than business with the working girl who will forever bear the mark of her Indian captivity, and a preacher’s daughter who has tender feelings for a young Native man torn between two worlds. All while the railway charges through the untamed land, changing the lives of all it touches forever.

This is the sort of western that works best for me—raw and dangerous. Bad things can happen to good people, and the rough land becomes home to the adventurous and the desperate, those wanting to start a new way of life, and those wanting to be rid of one that no longer suits them.

Night Song by Beverly JenkinsThe characters who populate such stories can come from a wide variety of backgrounds, with a diverse array of stories to tell. From classic authors such as Shirl Henke  or Alexis Harrington to new voices like Kaki Warner, writers of the western historical know that the right characters in the right setting can make an unforgettable impression.

Since the release of Night Song in 1994, Beverly Jenkins has brought readers Buffalo Soldiers, female doctors, train robbers, and lawmen as well as a fascinating look at the freed slaves who formed their own communities, leaving their unique mark on the western frontier.

Francine Rivers’s classic Redeeming Love, available in both inspirational and general market editions, retells a Biblical tale in a vivid western setting. Sold into prostitution as a child, Angel knows only hatred and pain until Michael Hosea confronts her with a love that will not be turned away.

The Heart of the West by Penelope WilliamsonIn Heart of the West, Penelope Williamson created an enduring classic. Cultured eastern heroine Clementine Kennicutt marries and leaves all she’s ever known to move west with one man, falls in love with his brother, and takes over a decade to finally reach her happy ending, but oh what a ride. Clementine and her love struggle to do the right thing, and readers feel every aching longing with them, in beautifully exquisite detail, their ending worth every trial along the way. The supporting cast includes women with their own struggles in this new land; a Chinese mail order bride, a survivor of Indian captivity and a former prostitute turned saloon owner, to name a few. Quite possibly my favorite western ever.

The Best Man by Maggie OsborneIf I had to name a queen of the western historical, I would place that crown firmly on the head of Maggie Osborne. Her western historicals with heroines who are often as hardscrabble—or more so—than the heroes, resonate with the beauty and struggle of a pivotal time in American history. The Best Man provides three romances in the tale of sisters Alex, Les and Freddy, each wounded in her own way, each determined to work a two thousand head cattle drive and prove herself ‘the best man’ to inherit their father’s business. Silver Lining brings to life the iconic character of Louise “Low” Down, a far from feminine prospector who wants only one reward for nursing an entire camp through a harrowing case of smallpox; a baby. So repulsive is Low Down that the prospectors have to draw lots to see who must do the deed, yet by the end of the story, she’s a woman to admire.

While there are months yet to new Hell on Wheels episodes, romances like these deliver all of the passion, peril, and panorama with none of the commercial breaks. Sounds like a good deal to me.


 

Anna C. Bowling considers writing historical romance the best way to travel through time and make the voices in her head pay rent. She welcomes visitors to her blog, Typing With Wet Nails and to follow her at Twitter.

Subscribe to this conversation (must be logged in):
Individual - You will receive an alert for each comment added to this post.
Digest - You will receive an end-of-day alert for all comments added to this post.
12 comments
BrooklynShoeBabe
1. BrooklynShoeBabe
Thanks for this post. I think these types of romance novels might appeal to my cowboy romances sensibility. :-)
BrooklynShoeBabe
2. JoyceG
I adore western romances, and have for years. I don't know if it's a result of all the western movies my parents took us to (at the good old drive in!) back in the 60's, or reading lots of books about the "pioneer days" when I was a kid, but I can't read enough good westerns (and frankly, there aren't enough on the market to battle all of the regency romances, which I read but am admittedly growing a bit weary of). I hope that the great success of the wonderfully talented Kaki Warner will spur more authors/publishers to offer more western romances for us fans of the genre! p.s. I thought Hell on Wheels was fantastic, and can't wait for the next season!
Heather Waters (redline_)
3. redline_
Love westerns! Great post, Anna. And how have I not seen Hell on Wheels? Downloaded the free pilot from Amazon Unbox last night and am hoping to watch when I go home today. Yay!
Anna Bowling
4. AnnaBowling
You're very welcome, BrooklynShoeBabe. Sounds like you have very good taste. :-)
Darlene Marshall
5. darlenemarshall
I'm a big fan of Hell on Wheels and some of the classic romance authors who did westerns. One you didn't mention is LaVyrle Spencer. Hummingbird is one of my favorite westerns of all time!
Anna Bowling
6. AnnaBowling
Joyce, it sounds like your love of westerns goes down deep. There's nothing like finding a genre that feels like home, and I'm all for variety in historical romance, so anything that spurs (pun intended) publisher interest can only be good.

redline_, I have no shame at enabling here. Our tastes tend to run similar so I'll be interested to hear how you like the Hell on Wheels pilot.

Darlene, I can't believe I left out LaVyrle Spencer. Hummingbird is a true classic. Years and November of the Heart (though the setting is eastern rather than western) utterly destroy me in the very best way. What are some of your other favorites?
Dolly Sickles
7. Dolly_Sickles
All my life, my mother read books with swelling seas and pirates, and cowboys and sunsets. It's nice to see western romances still in style.
Anna Bowling
8. AnnaBowling
Dolly, the classics never go out of style. I think your mother had very good taste. I can see those seas and sunsets now.
BrooklynShoeBabe
9. Karen H in NC
Hell on Wheels is one of the BEST programs on TV. Outstanding writing, directing and acting. The scene where that picture was taken from is one of the best scenes in the whole program! Loved the one with the preacher and the head too! LOL

Use to read western historical romances all the time years back. Then they sort of went out of favor and I've never gotten back into reading them. I think I might be missing something.
Anna Bowling
10. AnnaBowling
Karen, I couldn't agree more - the scene with the picture above was wonderful, and the preacher and the head actually made us jump. Didn't see that one coming.

Definitely give some of these suggestions a try. I'm looking forward to getting Marsha Canham's Under a Desert Moon, her lone western, for my ereader.
Anna Bowling
12. AnnaBowling
Jewelofthedark, I couldn't agree more. Can't wait to see what season two brings.
Post a comment