Wed
Sep 14 2011 12:23pm

Messing with a Classic: Joanna Trollope to Rewrite Jane Austen

Joanna Trollope

Yesterday, an article in the Guardian was headlined Joanna Trollope to rewrite Jane Austen.

The article announces that:

“The pairing is the first in a what the publisher has dubbed a ’major’ new series, in which it will team modern authors with Austen’s six novels, asking them to reimagine the books in a contemporary setting.”

My first impulse was to be outraged. How dare they think they need to update Jane Austen? Then, I stepped back for a moment and realized that my outrage was probably decades (maybe even a century) too late. Writers have been piggy-backing on Jane Austen for years and why shouldn’t Joanna Trollope, who is a really good writer, get on the bandwagon? Lord knows the publishing world has seen enough pretty awful interpretations of Jane Austen’s books and characters. Let’s see what Joanna Trollope can do.

Interestingly enough, yesterday I read an interview with David Liss, Author of The Twelfth Enchantment on the Austenprose blog. Mary Crawford (of Mansfield Park fame) is a major character in The Twelfth Enchantment and Mr. Liss says this of using Jane Austen’s characters in his fiction:

Writers always work in the shadows of their predecessors, and there are few writers as influential as Austen, who revolutionized both what kinds of characters were fit subjects for novels and how those characters can be brought to life. On the one hand, taking Austen’s characters and continuing their stories is an act of fandom and devotion, but given Austen’s influence on the form, I think it could also be argued that that’s what most novelists are doing most of the time anyhow.

I think, for many writers, he’s possibly quite right. What are we all doing but an act of fandom and devotion to Jane Austen? Bring it on, Joanna. Let’s see how you bring one of our favorite novels into the 21st century.


 

Myretta is the co-founder and current manager of The Republic of Pemberley, a pretty big Jane Austen web site. She is also a writer of Historical Romance. You can find her at her website,www.myrettarobens.com and on Twitter@Myretta

Photo of Joanna Trollope from http://www.guardian.co.uk/

Subscribe to this conversation (must be logged in):
Individual - You will receive an alert for each comment added to this post.
Digest - You will receive an end-of-day alert for all comments added to this post.
7 comments
Regina Thorne
1. reginathorn
I'm only astonished that the publishers seem to think they're dealing with a NEW CONCEPT! I mean, people have been rewriting Austen for contemporary settings for years (Bridget Jones, anyone? The first a hommage to Pride and Prejudice, the second to Persuasion? Not to mention the various Jane Austen novel plus supernatural creatures books that are currently popular and isn't there even a series in which Jane Austen herself is a detective?) Plus, the excellent Joan Aiken (whose children's book The Wolves of Willoughby Chase is a classic!) wrote a very nice re-imagining of Emma from the point of view of Jane Fairfax about twenty years ago (I read it in high school, so it's been probably longer than that!) And for my money, the best cinematic adaptation of Emma is DEFINITELY "Clueless" (and I also have a huge soft spot for "Bride and Prejudice", though alas, the two leads are terrible actors in that. But the secondary characters - particularly the Indian Mr. Collins - are priceless!)

The classics endure for a reason, I think, and no amount of rewriting and reimagining takes anything away from them. It just puts the bar kind of high for the poor contemporary author, who is sure to be taken to task for not being as witty, vibrant and elegant as the original.
Regina Thorne
2. reginathorn
I'm only astonished that the publishers seem to think they're dealing with a NEW CONCEPT! I mean, people have been rewriting Austen for contemporary settings for years (Bridget Jones, anyone? The first a hommage to Pride and Prejudice, the second to Persuasion? Not to mention the various Jane Austen novel plus supernatural creatures books that are currently popular and isn't there even a series in which Jane Austen herself is a detective?) Plus, the excellent Joan Aiken (whose children's book The Wolves of Willoughby Chase is a classic!) wrote a very nice re-imagining of Emma from the point of view of Jane Fairfax about twenty years ago (I read it in high school, so it's been probably longer than that!) And for my money, the best cinematic adaptation of Emma is DEFINITELY "Clueless" (and I also have a huge soft spot for "Bride and Prejudice", though alas, the two leads are terrible actors in that. But the secondary characters - particularly the Indian Mr. Collins - are priceless!)

The classics endure for a reason, I think, and no amount of rewriting and reimagining takes anything away from them. It just puts the bar kind of high for the poor contemporary author, who is sure to be taken to task for not being as witty, vibrant and elegant as the original.
Mo
3. Mo
Indeed. Simply tilting at windmills. No "updated" Jane Austen work will ever be as good as the original. Let any author who cares to step up to the plate and be judged poorly for it feel free, I say. There is a reason these works have stood the test of time.

Am I sorry to see this? Yes. Am I going to shout from the rooftops to stop it? No. I'll just vote with my wallet. :)
Myretta Robens
4. Myretta
@Mo. I really do think it's too late to stop this. As @reginathorne says (and I mentioned), it has been going on for far too long for this to be a new development.
rachel sternberg
5. rae70
I am just not that great of a fan of Jane Austen.. I had to read them for school and it was a chore to get through those books.
Louise Partain
6. Louise321
@Reginathorn -- Clueless and Bride and Prejudice -- two of my favorite updates.

I am not an Austen purist and I believe that the homage all the adaptations pay to her says much about her strength of characterization and her knowledge and insight into her own world of the Regency English gentry. Updating the bones of her plot will require the same strengths from the authors chosen.
Lennette Daniels
7. SoccerMomKnits
I love Jane Austen and I can't imagine anything being as good as the original but I sometimes think it would be interesting to see what someone good could do. I am not sure if she qualifies but I would be willing to read it and, of course, voice my opinion one way or another.
Post a comment